Broadcast News

Bookmark and Share
11/05/2018

Introduction To Network Topologies For IP – Part 1

News Image
This two-part article describes the various topologies that are available for use in IP-based broadcast systems. It considers their advantages and disadvantages, especially with respect to uncompressed and lightly compressed IP video applications, which may demand very high bandwidth. The article is based on dB Broadcast's unique experience in designing and implementing IP solutions for broadcasting and its work on state of the art projects for clients including Bloomberg Television and BBC Wales.

Traditionally, high-bandwidth video applications have used large SDI routers, often as a pair to provide failover protection. Many of the early implementations of high-bandwidth IP video applications took a similar approach by using a "big switch", that is a large switch chassis with multiple line cards. Aside from the obvious similarity to the traditional SDI router approach, all switch paths are 1:1 and as such inherently "non-blocking". Blocking occurs in networks, when there are insufficient traffic paths available to make all the desired connections. It is obvious that in high-bandwidth video applications, blocking must be avoided at all costs. In addition to being non-blocking, other advantages of the big switch include minimal cabling and capital cost, as well as simple configuration. The major disadvantage of this approach is that the switch can only be scaled up to the maximum number of available ports in the switch chassis. As scalability is desirable, then we must consider what alternative network topologies are available.

For many years, data centre networks have used a three-tier tree architecture. More recently, two-tier "Clos" network leaf-spine architectures (named after one of the original researchers Charles Clos), have become increasingly popular for medium to large scale data centre infrastructures.
A three-tier tree network consists of access, aggregation and core layers with the aggregation and access elements being separated into different "pods" based on their physical location. The bottom of the tree is the access layer where the hosts are connected via access switches. The middle aggregation layer is normally redundantly connected to the access layer via a Layer 2 "spanning tree". This is designed to prevent loops from being formed when switches or bridges are interconnected via multiple paths. The aggregation layer also provides connectivity to the top of the tree, which is known as the core layer. The core layer provides routing services to other parts of the data centre, as well as to remote locations.

Three-tier tree networks are simple to implement, economical with respect to cabling and require little configuration. Another advantage is that VLANs can be extended within each pod, so that servers can move freely within the pod without the need to change IP address and default gateway configurations.

The three-tier tree network topology however has several disadvantages. All traffic takes a single "best path" until the point at which it becomes oversubscribed and packets are dropped. Oversubscription is caused by the spanning tree algorithm, which deems alternative paths undesirable and uses "blocking" to close paths that would cause loops. Clearly, packet loss is highly undesirable in video applications.

Additionally, host-to-host latency varies depending on the traffic path used. This is a concern in high bandwidth video applications, where latency should be as low and as predictable as possible. As the path and number of hops could be different in each direction, this network topology is inherently susceptible to asymmetry, where the latency in the forward direction is different to the latency in the reverse direction. Excessive asymmetry can become an issue where Precision Time Protocol (PTP) is being used, as clock accuracy is based on the average of the latency in the forward and reverse directions.

To summarise this first part of the article, many early implementations of high-bandwidth IP video networks used a simple big switch, but the inherent scalability issues of this approach make it unlikely to prevail in the long-term. Also, the limitations of the three-tier tree topology mean that another architecture must be considered, and this will be discussed in part 2 of this article.

This article is also available in the May edition of Broadcast Film & Video.

dbbroadcast.co.uk
Solidmate Ltd Memory Card Hire London

Top Related Stories
Click here for the latest broadcast news stories.

15/03/2023
Caton Technology Partners With Osprey Video
Caton Technology has teamed up with Osprey Video to provide an integrated encoder and decoder which connects direct to IP circuits using Caton Transpo
21/04/2023
FOR-A To Showcase NDI®-Compatible Live Video Production Ecosystem
FOR-A is showcasing a fully NDI®-compatible live video production ecosystem at CABSAT 2023 (stand S1-M10, Dubai World Trade Centre, 16 – 18 May). The
20/04/2023
DTEN's D7x Video & Collaboration Solution Now Certified For Microsoft Teams
DTEN has announced that its DTEN D7X video conferencing & collaboration solution is now certified for Microsoft Teams. DTEN, in collaboration with Mic
19/04/2023
Zero Density Displays Virtual Video Bundle At NAB 2023
Zero Density has announced ZD | Virtual Studio, a new software bundle that lowers the barrier of entry into virtual production. ZD | Virtual Studio is
18/04/2023
Ross Video Teams Up With DreamWall
Ross Video has announced a new partnership with DreamWall, a leading provider of augmented reality and virtual studio services based in Charleroi, Bel
01/08/2018
The Switch To Host First Ever IBC Booth
The Switch® is to host its first ever booth at the IBC Show, showcasing a range of media solutions. On stand 1.F10, the patented customer controlled s
15/12/2023
Ross Video To Exit LED Display Business
Ross Video has announced plans to exit the LED display business and is now considering strategic opportunities for D3LED. While this process takes pla
14/12/2023
Broadpeak To Highlight Video Streaming Solutions At CES 2024
At CES 2024, Broadpeak® is to highlight innovative video streaming solutions that ensure an outstanding quality of experience (QoE) for live sports, b
14/12/2023
Brompton Brings Forward-Thinking LED Video Processing Technology
Earlier this year, Melbourne welcomed the inaugural Now or Never festival – a 16-day celebration of digital art and future thinking. The festival used
13/12/2023
Black Box To Feature IP-Based KVM And Video Wall Solutions
At ISE 2024 on Booth 5E330, Black Box® will feature IP-based KVM and video wall solutions that enhance control room workflows and empower operators by
12/12/2023
Reporter TV Chooses LiveU IP-Video EcoSystem
Reporter TV has selected the LiveU IP-video EcoSystem to expand its newsgathering capabilities all over India in the run-up to the 2024 Indian electio
29/11/2023
Brompton Technology To Demonstrate Next-Gen LED Video Processing
Brompton Technology is to demonstrate its latest technology at the LDI Show, taking place in the West Hall of the Las Vegas Convention Center from Dec
29/11/2023
Matrox Video Launches Single-Channel Maevex 7100 Series AVC/HEVC 4K60 Encoders
Matrox® Video has launched the new Matrox Maevex 7100 Series of single-channel 4K60 AVC/HEVC encoders. These two new lower-cost members of the Maevex
28/11/2023
Matrox Video Announces Plans For I/ITSEC 2023
Matrox® Video has announced its plans for I/ITSEC 2023, the world's largest modelling, simulation, and training event, which will take place 27 Novemb
28/11/2023
VITEC Delivers End-To-End IP Video Infrastructure Solution At RBB
Rundfunk Berlin-Brandenburg (RBB) is a public broadcaster responsible for the federal states of Berlin and Brandenburg in Germany. RBB is part of the