Broadcast News

Bookmark and Share
12/12/2014

Systems Integration: Hit By Slim Margins? (Pt. 1)

News Image
Coming out of IBC, one of the many hundreds of comments I recall for their serious implications was IABM chairman Peter White saying: "If you are a systems integrator you are probably not in a good place at the moment," writes industry expert George Jarrett.

He went on to say marking up hardware has died, and that unless SI companies offer added value services they will suffer "very slim margins indeed."

Did this mean that the market is turning its back on system integration specialists, or does it mean, in the new era of software-designed networks and the obsession with workflows, there is a need for a new breed of system integrators who can offer multiple added values?

The big IT system integrators have ignored the broadcast sector because it looks like small fry, years behind many bigger industries, but with so many media organisations looking to IT, IP and Cloud, and so much consolidation happening, it can only be a matter of time before they do peep. For this look at systems integration we spoke to three very confident outfits – TSL (as it combines with IPE), Broadcast Network and ATG Danmon – that see today's new technologies as just another change in a very long cycle.

Change is nothing new
"Peter White makes a good point. The traditional business model for a broadcast SI is to make its money from the resale of products and from professional services," said TSL director of solutions Bruce MacGregor.
"This model is largely broken when dealing with the larger broadcasters and media organisations who can buy equipment as cost effectively as the SI, or who are looking to work on an Op-Ex based model utilising the cloud.

"In order to react, we strongly believe that we need to adapt our business model and charge for the areas where we add true value, these are numerous and are often overlooked by the end users," he added. "Those that came immediately to mind are consultancy and design, risk management and mitigation, management of multiple third party vendors, project management and methodologies, cash flow management, installation and configuration, commissioning and support, documentation, and health and safety coordination.

"The nature of systems integration is changing but this is nothing new. Over the past 28 years since TSL was created we have experienced dramatic changes in not just technologies but workflows and ways to monetize and deliver content," said MacGregor. "This has always had an impact on the systems integration business and any good SI changes to adapt to the prevailing conditions."

Is this the reason the merger of TSL with IPE made so much sense to both parties, and is systems integration an old term that needs re-thinking?
"The coming together of the two companies allows us to increase our key engineering resources, and the skill sets of the respective staff complement each other," said MacGregor. "Systems integration has always been about making technologies talk to each other, however the key interfaces are now not modular cards but APIs and SOAP protocols. It has been this way for some time, and TSL has been producing file-based systems and workflows for well over a decade and all these systems have required levels of software integration and interfacing. The advent of the cloud has not fundamentally changed this; the platform has merely been abstracted."

How much SI work are the manufacturers doing, particularly software vendors? "In truth very little. There are some very large broadcast vendors who claim to be able to provide an end-to-end solution and will take on board a level of integration but only where it directly relates to their own products (or a subset of OEM products)," said MacGregor. "There is still a strong requirement for an independent systems integrator who can 'corral' the numerous different vendors, and ensure that the system will work as specified."

All round IBC I heard comments that offer encouragement to the SI sector, one being: "Technology has become so complex in certain areas it is not obvious how you are going to monetize it." Does this imply that the skills shortage is at the customer level?

"Technology is becoming more complex. It is very difficult for a broadcaster or end user to focus their efforts to analyse the vast array of technology choices out there," said MacGregor. "I do feel that customers need to change the way in which they engage with systems integrators. In the past it has been traditional for a broadcaster to issue an RFP that broadly outlines the requirement, and the SI would hurriedly throw together a design that would meet that requirement.

"The broadcaster would then award the contract based on that design and the associated price. It would only have been after the contract award that the design team would be able to spend any quality time with the end users and stakeholders to fully understand the requirements of the system," he added. "Often this means that large proportions of the proposed solution would be unsuitable and a significant amount of costly (in terms of both budget and time) change control would result."

MacGregor believes that the broadcast industry should take a lead from the construction sector and adopt a design and build methodology. "The broadcaster should appoint an SI to lead the design process as soon as the business case has been approved. This would allow the design team to meet with the end users and produce a detailed design package that meets the business requirements rather than the specification," he said. "Once the system has been fully and accurately defined it can be costed precisely, and hardware, software and services procured."

The article is also available to read in BFV online.

(IT/JP)
Solidmate Ltd Memory Card Hire London

Top Related Stories
Click here for the latest broadcast news stories.

29/10/2019
Video Progetti Completes Systems Integration Of Zero6
Video Progetti has announced that it has completed the systems integration of Zero6, the latest addition to Soul Movie's outside broadcast fleet. With
21/01/2019
ATG Danmon To Exhibit Range Of Systems Integration Services At BVE
ATG Danmon will exhibit its full range of systems integration services on stand G30-6 at BVE 2019 in London's ExCel, February 26-28. These include con
22/11/2018
Red Bee Media Provides Systems Integration Services For Altice France
Red Bee Media has provided Systems Integration Services for Altice France, creating a completely new Broadcast and News Center in Paris, France. The f
21/11/2018
ATG Danmon Announces Growth In Demand For Systems Integration
ATG Danmon reports continuing growth in demand for systems integration services throughout the broadcast industry as well as associated sectors such a
26/01/2018
Broadcast Systems Integration: Towards 2020
The start of a new year is a good time to take stock of recent trends in broadcast technology and to look ahead at upcoming developments. In an ideal
13/12/2016
The New Systems Integration
It is likely that future major systems developments will be based around IP connectivity and software-defined workflows. The logical consequence of th
12/12/2016
Trends In Broadcast Systems Integration
Watching NAB and IBC visitors trying the latest generation of immersive head-worn television displays this year was both informative and amusing, says
09/09/2014
Systems Integration For The File-Based Future
The transition from standard-definition to high-definition broadcasting generated a surge of systems integration business from the turn of the century
22/08/2014
ATG Danmon Appoint New Head Of Systems Integration
Jonathan Hughes, formerly of Gearhouse Broadcast, has been announced at the new Head of Systems Integration by ATG Danmon. Having studied at Ravensbou
24/01/2014
Systems Integration: Toughing It Out In The Broadcast Industry
Systems integration in the broadcast industry must be one of, if not the toughest of all systems integration, says Mark Errington, CEO OASYS Aut
19/12/2013
Flexible Functionality: Addressing Systems Integration
The most pressing challenges faced by manufacturers who deliver to both end-users and systems integrators are keeping pace with changes in technology
18/12/2013
Systems Integration: The Playbox Portfolio
PlayBox Technology has nearly 14 years of experience producing complete broadcast systems based on modular software and hardware. "We pioneered what i
18/12/2013
Broadcast Systems Integration In The Multimedia Age
While keeping up to date with the latest developments in integration solutions continues to prove a challenge, future-proofing is more important than
17/12/2013
Systems Integration In The New World Of IT
By Richard Welsh, SMPTE Governor for Europe, The Middle East, Africa and Central & South America Region and CEO at Sundog Media Toolkit Systems integr
14/08/2013
Danmon Brings Systems Integration To IBC
Danmon Systems Group has announced it will be present at this year's IBC show in Amsterdam, exhibiting a full range of services on stand 8.B51. Danmon